UPDATE: Sorry guys, this was supposed to be more of an open-ended question. I have a declarative writing style – I post my opinions, hit “Post”, then stomp off in a literary huff and wait for replies. So consider this a question: Do YOU think dating advice is useful? What has been most helpful for you? How do you take it in and make use of it?
And don’t let me get away with this stuff! Jeez, you guys…
See? Right out of the gate I’m hassling those advice-givers! Here’s the genesis of this question…like everyone else meandering the halls of singledom, I from time to time succumb and check out the various advice sites (and I’m not afraid to admit I’ve bought a book or two). With my time on Twitter, I’ve even become friends with some of the folks who write this stuff, and while I think they’re great people and often have good things to say, sometimes it’s just…well, it’s just nonsense.
Let’s back up a bit. When I first became single, my friends all took me under their wing and tried to get my dating legs under me. After a few months of intensive attention, I found I was even more awkward and unsure of myself than before! Why did this happen? Well, they all had different advice, is one reason why. It was confusing. And while the specifics were different, it all boiled down to this: Be yourself. Be confident. But stop doing and saying all those things that make you, you. Say this, not that. But don’t think about it. Pretty soon I couldn’t remember how to introduce myself to strangers! I finally had to give them all the boot, thank them for their efforts, and just cull through all that advice on my own, picking the stuff that really worked for me and fit my unique personality.
Dating advice, whether in books or online, is the same. The intentions are obviously good, but it’s very general, and it’s always flavored with the author’s experiences and personality. What works for me may not work for you, nes pa? At times I read this advice and think – I don’t want to be the person they’re describing here. And I wouldn’t want to date anyone who wanted me to be!
So in general, I lean towards the assumption that most dating advice is not useful. Now, there are always exceptions here – there are obviously those for whom social interaction is so foreign that they genuinely might not know about holding doors open or paying for dinner…but I’d say these folks are in the minority, and really have bigger battles to fight before they get to dating.
Which leads to my dating advice (I know, I know). Take all dating advice with a grain of salt. Read it, enjoy the stories, and see what fits your unique self. What can you incorporate? Do you lack confidence? Do you need inspirational examples of others overcoming their shyness? Then glom onto those bits of advice. There are always useful nuggets, but the most important advice ever is this: To thine own self be true. You can’t abandon who you are in an effort to be what someone else thinks you should be. What sort of love will you find that way? So think of dating advice as an opportunity to find your strengths and weaknesses and simply tweak them. And then get out there and find someone who fits you.